Instax vs Polaroid: which instant camera is right for you?

Instax vs Polaroid – the Polaroid 600 Vnyl and Polaroid OneStep 2 Stranger Things cameras, positioned next to the Instax Mini 8 and Instax Wide 100 cameras, lit with neon lighting
(Image credit: James Artaius)

Instax vs Polaroid is a tricky question for any lover of the chemical magic of instant photography. These two are the only real names in instant-film cameras – Polaroid is probably more well-known, but in raw sales terms, Instax is a lot more popular.

Both brands have spent the past few years busily filling out their ranges, and anyone trying to choose the best instant camera has a LOT of choice on their hands. Indeed, the sheer number of different cameras is pretty overwhelming, with both brands offering multiple film types and camera formats. And then there are also instant printers, which can connect to your phone and print images directly from your camera roll – both brands offer these.

So, the first thing we need to do when answering the Instax vs Polaroid question is to break down exactly what the options are…

Latest Videos FromDigital Camera World

Instax vs Polaroid: Current Instax cameras

Let's begin with Instax – these are the current models in the range:

Instax Mini 13
Instax Mini 41
Instax Mini 99
Instax Mini Evo 2
Instax Mini LiPlay+
Instax Square SQ40
Instax Square 2
Instax Wide 400
Instax Pal 2
Instax Mini Evo Cinema

As you can see, there are four broad categories of camera format: Instax Mini (which uses the smallest, rectangular film), Instax Square (using medium-sized square film), Instax Wide (which uses the largest rectangular film), and then there's the adorable Pal 2 – a tiny and completely digital camera that has no ability to print photographs unless connected to one of the Instax Link portable printers. For this reason, I'll largely be skirting over it here.

The differences between the other cameras are largely cosmetic, so essentially you're choosing between the smallest cameras that take the smallest photos, mid-sized cameras that take square photos, and a big giant camera that takes the biggest photos.

All Instax cameras – with the exception of the Evo, LiPlay and Pal, which we'll get to – are analog, and expose photographs instantly onto film using photochemistry. They all feature auto-exposure, for point-and-shoot simplicity, and with the exception of the Mini 99 and Wide 400, they all boast a tiny selfie mirror on the front, so you can easily compose your self-portraits.

Fujifilm Instax Mini 99 surrounded by Instax Mini prints

The Instax Mini 99 offers more advanced control than other Instax Mini cameras – but lacks a selfie mirror. (Image credit: Gareth Bevan / Digital Camera World)

While all the other analog Instaxes largely share the same features, the Wide 400 features a tripod socket (for taking wide group shots) and a number of flash and exposure compensation options – though it needs a clip-on lens to shoot close-up shots and isn't great for selfies (as its minimum focus distance is 40cm, compared to the 30cm of other Instax models).

The Mini 99, meanwhile, is the most advanced and creative of the bunch, mainly due to having a series of colored LEDs inside the camera that can illuminate during exposures to create in-camera effects such as light leaks.

Back to the mini Evo series and mini LiPlay+, which are clever hybrid digital instant cameras. They can either expose images instantly (like their analog counterparts), save them digitally (to internal memory or a microSD card), or act as portable printers to "print" existing images from your smartphone onto Instax film. Like the Pal, they can also shoot remotely by using the Instax app to fire the shutter from your phone.

And you wouldn't necessarily think to put 'Instax' and 'video' in the same sentence, but Fujifilm has bucked expectations by introducing the Fujifilm Instax Mini Evo Cinema, a hybrid model styled after classic Super 8 video cameras. It shoots 600 x 800 video in 24p, and it can print out stills on Instax Mini film.

Instax vs Polaroid: Current Polaroid cameras

The Polaroid Mod instant camera (Image credit: Hillary K Grigonis / Future)

While the Instax range is quite intimidating, Polaroid's current camera offering is much more straightforward – and they are all analog:

Polaroid Go Gen 3
Polaroid Now
Polaroid Now+
Polaroid Flip
Polaroid Mod
Polaroid I-2
Polaroid 600

The Polaroid Go, now in its third generation, is the smallest analog instant camera in the world, capable of fitting in the palm of a hand. It is essentially Polaroid's answer to the Instax Mini cameras – but unlike its rival's tiny rectangular photos, the Go produces tiny square photos.

The Now and Now+ are new versions of the iconic Polaroid camera, which produces familiar medium-sized square-shaped photos. These modern cameras have built-in batteries, which means they can take the newer i-Type film as well as traditional 600 film (more on this below).

The Now+ (also on Gen 3) is a creative camera, with lens filters and offers full manual control – so it's more than just a point-and-shoot camera. It even has a bunch of creative tools accessible via a phone app (including light painting and aperture priority) and also has a tripod mount.

The I-2 is something quite different, as it is the first ever fully manual Polaroid and has the brand's sharpest ever lens. Well, it's fully manual except for the focus; and it doesn't just boast autofocus, it boasts LiDAR autofocus. The I-2 is probably the best instant camera that has ever been made, but it comes with an enormous $600 / £600 / AU$1,000 price tag.

But it's not the only Polaroid camera with focusing capability. One of our favorites among the entire range is the Polaroid Flip. It's so-named because it features a chunky flip-up top, which houses a powerful flash and a sonar autofocus sensor. It's not quite as sophisticated as the LiDAR system on the I-2, but it's still very impressive.

More recently, Polaroid has attempted to bring some of the high-end creativity of the I-2 into a more affordable and beginner-friendly camera, the result of which is the Polaroid Mod. This model features a number of creative modes accessed via a simple, comprehensible mode dial around the lens – these include double exposure, split mode, light painting and motion freeze.

Lastly, a quick note on Polaroid 600s, which are not new or, technically, even current cameras. However, since the format is so beloved, Polaroid sells refurbished 600 cameras as and when it has stock (as do companies like Retrospekt). So bear in mind that these are vintage cameras brought back to life, and they do not accept the new i-Type film – they only work with 600 film cartridges, which have a battery in them.

Instax vs Polaroid: The film

(Image credit: Fujifilm)

With so many different formats, regardless of which side of the Instax vs Polaroid debate you fall on, you're inevitably going to ask "What type of instant film do I need?"

The key difference between Instax and Polaroid films is in their photochemistry; Instax shots take around 90 seconds to develop, while Polaroids take up to 15 minutes. The qualities and characteristics of each film are also very different, which I'll cover in the Performance section below.

Instax offers three distinct film types, all of which come in packs of 10 exposures as standard. Instax Mini produces credit card-sized 2.13 x 3.4" rectangular prints, Instax Square delivers medium-sized 2.83 x 3.39" square prints, and Instax Wide produces the largest 4.3 x 3.42" rectangular prints.

All formats offer color and black-and-white film, with Mini and Square also coming in a variety of colored, patterned and limited edition film featuring non-white borders around the prints.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Instax vs Polaroid: film size comparison

Film

Overall size

Image size

Instax Mini

54 x 85mm

46 x 62mm

Instax Square

86 x 72mm

62 x 62mm

Instax Wide

108 x 85mm

99 x 62mm

Polaroid Go

53.9 x 66.6mm

46 x 47mm

Polaroid / SX-70

88 x 107mm

79 x 79mm

Polaroid 8x10

215 x 325mm

190 x 241mm

Polaroid offers four kinds of film, all of which come in standard packs of eight exposures – so you obviously get two fewer photos per pack than Instax. Polaroid Go film produces tiny 2.623 x 2.122" signature square shots.

"Regular" Polaroid film comes in two varieties: i-Type and 600. Both produce identically-sized 4.233 x 3.483" photos, but the latter comes in film cartridges with a built-in battery. These are required by Polaroid 600s, so these cameras can only use 600 film.

Modern Polaroids like the Now and Now+, however, have their own batteries – so they can accept both i-Type and 600 film. Other than the battery, though, there is no difference between the two film types in terms of quality or performance.

The other two types of film aren't really relevant to this discussion. Polaroid SX-70 film (4.233 x 3.483") is exclusively for SX-70 cameras, which are no longer sold by the company. Polaroid 8x10 film (12.8 x 8.5") is exclusively for large format cameras with an appropriate camera back.

Instax vs Polaroid: Printers

Instax's line of Link printers (from left to right): the Mini Link, Square Link and Link Wide (Image credit: James Artaius)

Both Instax and Polaroid offer their own printers using the same instant film used in their instant cameras. However, they each go about this in very different ways.

Instax has focused on producing some of the best portable printers that use film instead of paper. So, as is the case with its cameras, its Link printers make use of the three Instax formats – the Instax Mini Link 3, Instax Square Link and Instax Link Wide 2. (As noted above, the Instax Mini LiPlay+, Instax Mini Evo 2 and Instax Mini Evo Cinema all offer this same function.)

All three devices connect wirelessly to your smartphone (or a very limited selection of Fujifilm cameras), enabling you to edit and print your photographs directly onto film. This means that literally any photo (or still from any video) on your phone can be used, whether it's a meme you screenshotted from Instagram or a commercial photo you shot in the studio with an elaborate lighting setup.

The Polaroid Lab effectively has a built-in camera, which takes a photo of your phone screen (Image credit: James Artaius)

Polaroid's approach for a while was altogether different. The Polaroid Lab, which used to be Polaroid's only instant printer, looks quite different from its Instax counterpart in that it isn't a portable pocket-sized printer; rather, it's a kooky-looking plastic device designed for a desktop – and it looks like it would be more at home in an optician's office.

Look closer and you'll notice that it kind of looks like a Polaroid camera laid on its back with a tray on top of the lens. Which is, in fact, exactly what it is. Where the Instax Link printers receive images digitally, the Polaroid Lab "scans" them by taking a photo of the image on your phone screen. It then exposes a picture of a picture on your phone screen, which is all a bit meta – and can result in fairly ropey image quality.

While the Instax Link printers produce image quality identical to Instax cameras, the Lab is much more temperamental (since it relies on the brightness and calibration of your phone screen, which combined with the photochemical process can be pretty hit-and-miss). Check out my full Polaroid Lab review to see what I mean.

More recently, Polaroid has added some more conventional pocket printers to the line – the Hi·Print series. There are three in the range currently: the Polaroid Hi·Print 2x3, the Polaroid Hi·Print 3x3, and the Polaroid Hi·Print 4x6. The numbers refer to the size of the prints, expressed in inches, so you need to also get the correct size of paper. They print reasonably quickly using dye-sublimation technology, and image quality on the semi-gloss paper is solid, with decent color rendition, brightness, contrast and tonal range.

Instax vs Polaroid: Special editions

The Instax Mini Hello Kitty edition is ridiculously cute (and pretty large!) (Image credit: James Artaius)

With instant cameras being so affordable, giftable and collectable, Instax and Polaroid both release special editions of their cameras to keep fans constantly interested.

These cameras are typically inspired by pop culture icons. Instax, for instance, struck gold with its Taylor Swift-themed Instax Square SQ6 (which drove camera sales to 900,000 per month!), while Polaroid has collaborated with everyone from Keith Haring to Star Wars, culminating in the Mandalorian Polaroid.

Most of the time, these cameras simply feature alternate colorways, decals or other cosmetic changes. Instax went one further with its Instax Mini Hello Kitty, though, which featured a completely new body in the shape of Hello Kitty's head.

Polaroid has always had the coolest special editions, such as the Polaroid Originals OneStep 2 Stranger Things Edition (Image credit: Alis Volat)

It's not just cameras, though – both brands also produce special and limited edition film as well. Often these new films come in tandem with a new camera, such as The Mandalorian and Keith Haring product range.

Most times, though, the manufacturers put out standalone special edition film. This can range from Polaroid's experimental film stock like the Polaroid Green Duochrome, accidental stock like Polaroid Reclaimed Blue, and celebrity-themed David Bowie Polaroid film.

Instax is more apt to go for popular IP such as Instax Snoopy film, as well as stock based on properties like Pokémon and Disney. However, we've now also had a Pokémon x Polaroid collab – so Poké-fans are spoiled for choice.

(Image credit: James Artaius)

Instax vs Polaroid: Performance

All the cool cameras and crazy film in the world is no good if the pictures are rubbish! So which instant camera has the best image quality? Well, unhelpfully, the answer is… it depends.

If you're looking for conventional image quality – sharpness, contrast, color rendition, exposure – then I would have to say that the Instax family is my favorite. This is true across all three formats (Mini, Square and Wide) as it is a product of Instax's photochemistry.

As noted, Instax prints take about 90 seconds to develop – which also means they are the best option if speed is of the essence (these are, after all, instant cameras). In short, if you want pictures that look most like traditional photographs, this is the way to go. Take a look at some samples:

Some samples of Instax photographs (Square above, Mini below) (Image credit: Gareth Bevan)

With Polaroid film, you are making a very distinct stylistic choice: these photographs are about character rather than convention when it comes to image quality.

Polaroid cameras and film produce what can only be described as more "vintage-looking" images. Exposures can be more washed out, with smeary oversaturated colors and a dream-like aesthetic. Where Instax film renders more authentic color and hue, Polaroid skews much more magenta.

In addition, because Polaroids take up to 15 minutes to develop (and contrary to what André 3000 says, DO NOT shake it!), they are not the format of choice if you want instant gratification – or if you're out shooting with friends or family on a sunny day, if you don't have somewhere dark (like a camera bag) to stash the prints while they expose.

It's also worth noting that the full-size Polaroids (Now, Now+, I-2, Flip, Mod) boast much clearer exposures than the Go indoors, thanks to the larger and more powerful flash. They also handle overexposure much better when shooting outdoors. Here are some samples:

A selection of Polaroid photos (full-size Polaroid at the top, Polaroid Go at the bottom) (Image credit: James Artaius)

Instax vs Polaroid: Verdict

If you're looking for the industry standard, it's Instax – which is actually the most successful brand across the entire camera industry, not just instant photography. It's the most affordable, the most versatile (when it comes to offering three different size formats), the most instant, and offers the most conventional image quality.

However, Polaroid has the hip factor. It offers the coolest collaborations and cameras, the experimental film stocks are ridiculously neat, the Now+ has the most all-round advanced features, and the characteristics are the most authentically "vintage" for that retro look on your photographs.

Ultimately, it all comes down to that look – and whether you want a crunchy contrasty vibe (Instax) or a more psychedelic throwback feel (Polaroid). At the end of the day, both formats are fantastic – but they're both about the feeling, so go with the one that calls out to you!

(Image credit: James Artaius)
James Artaius
Editor in Chief

James has 25 years experience as a journalist, serving as the head of Digital Camera World for 7 of them. He started working in the photography industry in 2014, product testing and shooting ad campaigns for Olympus, as well as clients like Aston Martin Racing, Elinchrom and L'Oréal. An Olympus / OM System, Canon and Hasselblad shooter, he has a wealth of knowledge on cameras of all makes – and he loves instant cameras, too.