Best compact system camera: 6 top CSCs go head to head

Best compact system camera: 6 top CSCs go head to head

Some CSCs are more compact than others, while others offer a wealth of sophisticated features. In this group test we put 6 of the top mirrorless cameras on the market to the test to find the best compact system camera for your money.

Best compact system camera: 6 top CSCs go head to head

Mirrors add weight and bulk to your camera and potentially introduce bounce-blur, but compact system cameras (CSCs) omit the reflex mirror.

All but the Leica in this group also do away with any kind of optical viewfinder, substituting it with a high-res electronic finder.

The net result is a relatively compact camera that’s smaller and more lightweight than a traditional digital SLR, yet retains the benefit of interchangeable lenses.

Some of the top-end CSCs on the market offer direct-access shooting controls, image sensors of anything up to full-frame in size, and a wealth of sophisticated features. Some are as big and weighty as SLR bodies.

The emphasis for the cameras in this test is not so much on downsizing or compactness, but simply delivering a great camera that enables creative photography. Let’s take a closer look at what all the cameras have to offer…

DON’T MISS: The best camera money can buy – 6 premium bodies go head to head

The Contenders

Fujifilm X-T1, £880 / $980
Available in original black or graphite, the 16.3MP APS-C format XT-1 from Fujifilm serves up a feast of hands-on controls and lots of new tricks.

Leica M-P 
(typ 240), 
£5,150 / $7,000
The classic rangefinder camera in its latest digital guise, with a full-frame 24MP CMOS sensor. Who needs autofocus anyway?

Olympus OM-D E-M1, 
£900 / $1,300
Small, tough and beautifully built, the 16.3MP E-M1 takes pride of place in Olympus’s Micro Four Thirds stable.

Panasonic Lumix DMC-GH4 
£1,050 / $1,700
More of a heavyweight Micro Four Thirds camera than the diminutive Olympus E-M1, the 16.1MP GH4 boasts 4K video.

Samsung NX1 £1,300 / $1,300
The latest Samsung powerhouse is a 28.2MP APS-C format camera with a very fast 15fps burst rate and impressive video capture resolution.

Sony Alpha 7 Mark II 
£1,400 / $1,500
The second edition of this 24MP Sony is the first ever full-frame camera to feature sensor-shift stabilisation.

SEE MORE
Canon cameras – the full and complete range explained from IXUS to EOS
Nikon cameras – the full and complete range explained
Sony cameras – the full and complete range explained
Panasonic cameras – the full and complete range explained
Fuji cameras – the full and complete range explained
Olympus cameras – the full and complete range explained

Best compact system camera: 01 Fujifilm X-T1

X-T1

£880 / $980
The new ‘Graphite’ edition of the Fuji X-T1 adds features that the earlier Black edition also gets via a firmware upgrade. New tricks include a menu option for switching between the mechanical shutter and a faster electronic shutter, with speeds of up to 1/32,000 sec.

There’s also a Classic Chrome addition to the range of film emulations, plus a Natural Live View option, which displays previews as nature intended, rather than applying any in-camera effects.

A forthcoming update to V4 firmware will take the camera further still, with greater autofocus accuracy and tracking performance, plus a range of other enhancements.

The X-T1 packs an APS-C sensor with a modest pixel count of 16.3MP, fast hybrid phase/contrast detection autofocus system and a brisk 8fps burst rate, into a weather-resistant magnesium alloy body.

The X-T1’s plethora of dials makes it easy for photographers to get to almost any advanced shooting setting without having to navigate menus.

That’s welcome, considering the LCD isn’t a touchscreen, although it does have a tilt facility for easing high or low-level shooting.

Wi-Fi connectivity is built in, unlike the flash module, which is supplied as an external clip-on unit.

SEE MORE: DSLR vs Mirrorless – key differences explained

Performance
Sophisticated controls are matched by strong performance. Autofocus is quick, and metering is accurate and consistent.

Dynamic range enhancements work well to reign in highlights and boost shadow detail, while Fujifilm’s film emulations such as Provia (standard), Velvia (vivid) and Astia (soft) yield beautiful results.

Features: 4/5
Build/Handling: 5/5
Image Quality: 5/5
Value: 5/5

Overall: 5/5

SEE MORE: The 12 most popular cameras of Digital Camera World readers

Best compact system camera: 02 Leica M-P (typ 240)

Best compact system camera: 02 Leica M-P (typ 240)

£5,150 / $7,000
The Leica brand has been the subject of many a heated discussion over the decades, and the M-P seems certain to further that tradition.

Some simply won’t be able to get their heads around the notion of a 21st-century digital camera on which you can only set focusing and aperture via an attached lens.

Mod cons like Wi-Fi connectivity and touch control are entirely lacking, and the sensitivity range is comparatively stunted at ISO 200-3,200 (100-6,400 expanded).

The price will also be a major talking point: with the 35mm f/2 lens pictured above, the camera costs £7,300 / $10,000.

The top and bottom plates are hewn from solid brass, and the shell is magnesium alloy. The body is quite chunky yet slab-like in design, without any moulded grip areas.

This can make handling feel awkward and insecure, especially considering that the Leica is the heaviest camera in the group at 690g, excluding the lens.

The rangefinder system takes some getting used to, but it’s well implemented. The optical viewfinder incorporates guide lines to show how much you’ll be able to fit into images when using different focal lengths of lens.

A key upgrade in the M-P, however, is that it uses a CMOS rather than a CCD image sensor.

Performance
Despite its bare-bones layout of controls, the Leica is capable of gorgeous image quality, in both raw and JPEG modes.

However, image noise is more noticeable than in the competing cameras in this group, especially at sensitivity settings of ISO 1,600 and upwards.

Features: 2/5
Build/Handling: 4/5
Image Quality: 4/5
Value: 2/5

Overall: 3/5

SEE MORE: Best budget camera – 6 top options under £350 / $450 tested and rated

Best compact system camera: 03 Olympus OM-D E-M1

Best compact system camera: 03 Olympus OM-D E-M1

£900 / $1,300
The most upmarket of Olympus’s OM-D range of CSCs, the E-M1 is one of the smallest and lightest models on test. Slightly bigger and heavier than the Fujifilm X-T1, the E-M1 has a smaller image sensor, but the same pixel count of 16.3MP.

The Olympus OM-D E-M1 boasts a hybrid autofocus system with phase/contrast detection. Autofocus is available on heritage Four Thirds lenses, as well as Micro Four Thirds lenses made by Olympus and other manufacturers.

Further highlights include a five-axis sensor-shift image stabiliser, directly competing with the Sony A7 II camera. It works well for both stills and video shooting, as well as giving a stabilised view in the electronic viewfinder and rear LCD screen.

The latter is a high-res touchscreen with up/down tilt facility. It’s neat being able to touch areas of the screen to assign autofocus points, but Olympus missed a trick by not extending touch control to menu navigation.

Despite the E-M1’s small size, it’s comfortable thanks to the deep sculpting in the finger grip to enable a secure hold. Handling is enhanced by direct-access buttons and dials, providing shortcuts to settings.

SEE MORE: 6 reasons why a compact system camera (CSC) is better than a DSLR

Performance
Metering is consistent and accurate, and autofocus is swift. The auto white balance system tends to stray to the warm side, especially in direct sunlight.

With the relatively large 2.0x focal length magnifier of the Micro Four Thirds system, it’s more difficult to get a tight depth of field, but Micro Four Thirds lenses tend to be quite compact. Retention of fine detail in images could be better.

Features: 4/5
Build/Handling: 4/5
Image Quality: 4/5
Value: 4/5

Overall: 4/5

SEE MORE: Canon EOS 1200D vs Nikon D3300 vs Pentax K-500 – which is the best entry-level DSLR?

Best compact system camera: 04 Panasonic Lumix GH4

Panasonic cameras full range: Lumix GH4

£1,050 / $1,700
Compared with the other Micro Four Thirds cameras, the GH4 looks bigger and beefier.

The increase in height enables the fitment of a built-in flash module, and part of the heavier weight is accounted for by a larger and higher-capacity battery, capable of 500 shots between recharges, compared with the Olympus E-M1’s 330 shots.

Both take the same mount Micro Four Thirds lenses, although the GH4 has purely contrast-detection autofocus, rather than the E-M1’s hybrid system.

One of the improvements over the older GH3 is that the Panasonic GH4 captures 4K Ultra High Definition video.

There are also knock-on benefits for stills shooting, with a fast and powerful image processor that enables a burst rate of up to 12fps.

The GH4 has a clear, high-resolution electronic viewfinder, and a high-res LCD screen to match. The GH4 is the only camera in this group to feature full screen articulation rather than just a tilt facility.

It’s well connected too, with built-in Wi-Fi and NFC (Near Field Communication) connectivity.

The handling benefits from SLR-like styling that incorporates a deeply sculpted finger grip and plentiful controls for the finer points of shooting settings.

SEE MORE: 24 camera features every beginner must memorize

Performance
One thing that isn’t updated in the GH4 is the pixel count of the sensor, which remains at 16.1MP.

Image quality is very good overall, but you can sometimes feel short-changed by the level of fine detail that’s reproduced in images. Even so, it hangs on to detail better at high ISO settings than the competing E-M1.

Features: 5/5
Build/Handling: 4/5
Image Quality: 4/5
Value: 4/5

Overall: 4/5

READ MORE

Canon vs Nikon: the DSLR comparison you’ve been waiting for!
99 Common Photography Problems (and how to solve them)
10 things you may not know about your camera, but probably should
Canon EOS 5DS / 5DS R vs Nikon D810 – 9 key differences to know
Nikon D810 vs Canon EOS 5D Mark III – full-frame DSLRs go head to head