I gave up color photography for one year. Four years on, I still haven’t gone back!

Leica M11-D held up to the eye in black and white
(Image credit: Future)

Four years ago, I set myself what I thought was a simple photographic challenge: to shoot only in black and white for a year.

No color film, no color digital work, no “just in case” versions sitting on a hard drive waiting to be edited later. Just monochrome, in every sense of the word, both digitally and on film.

Shot on a Nikon F5 with a 50mm f/1.4G lens, film stock Fomapan 400 (Image credit: Future / Sebastian Oakley)

At the time, I thought it might sharpen my eye, discipline my approach, and perhaps teach me something about light, form, and composition that color had allowed me to overlook. What I did not expect was that four years later, I would still be here, still shooting in black and white, still enjoying every second of it, and with very little desire to go back.

That may sound strange to some, especially when photography is so often tied to the richness of color. A sunset burning across the sky, a sea turned deep turquoise by the light, the warmth of autumn, the neon glow of a city at night - these are all things photographers are supposed to want to capture.

Yet one of the greatest gifts black and white photography has given me is the ability to appreciate those moments without feeling the need to photograph them. I can now watch a wonderful sunset and simply enjoy it. I can look at a powerfully colored sea and store it in my mind, rather than instinctively reaching for a camera.

In many ways, that has been one of the most freeing parts of the whole experience. Choosing black and white has not made me blind to color; if anything, it has made me more aware of it. The difference is that I no longer feel compelled to translate every beautiful color moment into a photograph. Some things are better left as memories, held privately, exactly as they were seen.

Shot on a Leica M240 with 50mm Summilux f/1.4 ASPH. (Image credit: Future)

The magic of black and white photography, for me, is that it is not what the eye truly sees. It removes a layer of information that we rely on every day, and in doing so, it opens a door into a slightly different dimension of reality. Without color, the ordinary can become strange, the mundane can become important, and life’s everyday moments can be seen for what they often are: honest, simple, and quietly extraordinary.

That is where black and white have changed the way I look at the world. It strips things back. It asks more from the photographer and, I think, more from the viewer too. You are no longer being guided by a bright red coat, a blue sky, or the golden tone of late afternoon light. Instead, you are left with gesture, shadow, texture, shape, expression, and feeling. The image has to stand on those things alone.

There is something deeply emotional about that process. You can take a colorful landscape, remove the color entirely, and suddenly the same scene tells a completely different story. What was once beautiful in an obvious way can become lonely, dramatic, peaceful, or even unsettling. Black and white allows you to see past what is physically there and, like a painter, apply your own vision to the scene.

Shot with a Niko D3 and 80-200mm f/2.8 (Image credit: Future)

I fully admit that I also buy into the great cliché of black and white being “timeless.” It is a well-worn phrase, but that does not make it any less true. You can shoot a set of images in 2026 and, depending on the subject, the light, and the treatment, they can feel as though they belong to 1926. That is not just nostalgia; it is a creative tool. It allows a photographer to blur time, to remove certain modern distractions, and to tell a story in a way that feels less tied to the moment it was made.

For me, black and white has become a kind of poetic caption for the color moment I remember in my head. The color may not be present in the final photograph, but it still exists somewhere in the making of it. I remember the warmth of the light, the shade of the sea, the color of the coat, the tone of the sky. The viewer may not see those things, but somehow the emotion of them can still live inside the image.

That, I think, is one of the most fascinating things about monochrome photography. You can remove the color from the frame, but you cannot always remove it from the mind. The brain fills in gaps, imagines tones, and builds its own version of what might have been there. Black and white gives just enough information, then lets memory and imagination do the rest.

Shot on a Leica M240 with a 50mm Summilux f/1.4 ASPH. (Image credit: Future)

What began as an experiment has now become part of how I see. I no longer think of black and white as a limitation, but as a language. It is not about rejecting color because color is somehow lesser.

It is about choosing a different way of speaking. It is about simplifying the frame until what remains feels closer to the truth I wanted to express.

Will I ever go back to shooting color? Honestly, I am not sure. This little one-year challenge has lasted far longer than I ever expected, and perhaps that says everything. Four years on, I still find joy in it. I still find new things to learn. I still find myself surprised by how different the world can look when color is taken away.

Shot on Leica M2 with Leica 35mm Summarit-M f/2.5 (Image credit: Future)

Maybe one day color will call me back in some serious way, but for now, I am more than happy where I am. Black and white has given me a way to photograph the world without feeling the need to possess all of it.

It has taught me to look harder, feel more, and sometimes, when the sunset is too beautiful for words, simply put the camera down and remember it.

Sebastian Oakley
Ecommerce Editor

For nearly two decades Sebastian's work has been published internationally. Originally specializing in Equestrianism, his visuals have been used by the leading names in the equestrian industry such as The Fédération Equestre Internationale (FEI), The Jockey Club, Horse & Hound, and many more for various advertising campaigns, books, and pre/post-event highlights.

He is a Fellow of the Royal Society of Arts, holds a Foundation Degree in Equitation Science, and holds a Master of Arts in Publishing. He is a member of Nikon NPS and has been a Nikon user since his film days using a Nikon F5. He saw the digital transition with Nikon's D series cameras and is still, to this day, the youngest member to be elected into BEWA, the British Equestrian Writers' Association.

He is familiar with and shows great interest in 35mm, medium, and large-format photography, using products by Leica, Phase One, Hasselblad, Alpa, and Sinar. Sebastian has also used many cinema cameras from Sony, RED, ARRI, and everything in between. He now spends his spare time using his trusted Leica M-E or Leica M2, shooting Street/Documentary photography as he sees it, usually in Black and White.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.