Former Associated Press photojournalist on the ground at Kamala Harris rally in Detroit says images are real

People attend a campaign event for Democratic presidential candidate, U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris and Democratic vice presidential candidate Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz on August 7, 2024 in Detroit, Michigan
Shot of the Kamala Harris and supporters at Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport on August 7. Shot with a Sony A9 III and 24-70mm lens (Image credit: Andrew Harnik / Getty Images)

Donald Trump has openly accused Vice President Kamala Harris of using AI to generate images of the large supportive crowd that met her in Detroit recently. 

Posting on his self-owned social media platform Truth Social on Sunday, Trump wrote:

“Has anyone noticed that Kamala CHEATED at the airport? There was nobody at the plane, and she “A.I.’d” it, and showed a massive “crowd” of so-called followers, BUT THEY DIDN’T EXIST! She was turned in by a maintenance worker at the airport when he noticed the fake crowd picture, but there was nobody there, later confirmed by the reflection of the mirror like finish on the Vice Presidential Plane. 

“She’s a CHEATER. She had NOBODY waiting, and the “crowd” looked like 10,000 people! Same thing is happening with her fake “crowds” at her speeches. This is the way the Democrats win Elections, by CHEATING - And they’re even worse at the Ballot Box. She should be disqualified because the creation of a fake image is ELECTION INTERFERENCE. Anyone who does that will cheat at ANYTHING!”

Trump doubled down on this theory despite numerous citizens sharing images and videos of the crowd showing thousands of attendees, as well as the press photographers capturing almost every angle of the crowd.

Getty photographer Andrew Harnik was at the event, who has previously worked with the Associated Press and has been recognized by the White House News Photographers Association for the past 16 years. He was awarded the Political Photograph of the Year in 2012, and again in 2017.

Speaking to the Daily Beast, Harnik said the crowd was “significantly large enough,” and that “It was a large crowd, and the pictures that I took that are on the Getty website speak to that.

Trump is seemingly still angry at having to manipulate photographs of his own inauguration crowd in 2017. 

Exclusive documents released by the Guardian newspaper in 2018 allegedly proved that a government photographer at the time edited official images of Trump’s inauguration.

They seemed to show that the photographer had attempted to make the crowds appear bigger by cropping out the empty space “where the crowd ended” for photos requested by Trump on the first morning of his presidency. This was after reports he was angered that images of his crowd appeared much smaller than Obama’s in 2009. 

Trump’s rhetoric further encouraged the blossoming right-wing conspiracy theory, which seemingly coincided with far-right filmmaker and supporter of Trump’s ‘win’ in the 2020 election Dinesh D’Souza . They asserted that it was a fake crowd, posting a picture of Air Force Two.

“Check the reflection in the plane,” he wrote, “Does this look like a real picture to you?”

Harnik explained to the Daily Beast that he used a zoom lens, allowing him to capture high quality images of the entire event without leaving his vantage point. He also said that a zoom lens can sometimes give images a “flat” look, and make a subject appear closer, in this instance a plane to a crowd.

“This plane is actually a pretty far distance from the crowd,” he added.

Take a look at our guides to the best standard zoom lenses, the best telephoto lenses, and the best camera for professionals

Leonie Helm
Staff Writer

After graduating from Cardiff University with an Master's Degree in Journalism, Media and Communications Leonie developed a love of photography after taking a year out to travel around the world. 

While visiting countries such as Mongolia, Kazakhstan, Bangladesh and Ukraine with her trusty Nikon, Leonie learned how to capture the beauty of these inspiring places, and her photography has accompanied her various freelance travel features. 

As well as travel photography Leonie also has a passion for wildlife photography both in the UK and abroad.