landscape portfolio, your thoughts?

[level200]

HI Guys

I have recently decided to really get into Landscape photography, I have had a few photos up on the Critique section and finally feel brave enougth to show them to the Landscape section for your expert opinion.

I'm still learning so any feedback and comments will be great.

Cheers
John

Saltburn Sunset:



Dunstanborough castle blues:

image removed!

Starfish Sunset:

image removed!

Dunstanborough rock mist:

image removed!

Gibsons Cave:

image removed!

[alfbranch]

John
Generally quite good IMO.
I love the first shot as stated elsewhere.
The secon is too cold and dark for my liking.
The third the starfish is in the wrong place as it has me looking at the bottom of the shot and not much else think rule of thirds and it could be move though. The starfish probably should have had a shot of its own.
The fourth shot is great I would be tempted to play with a bit more but you did a great job on the day. maybe some more dodging on thehighlights.
I am not sure about the last but the shutter speed is just right but the rocks behind the waterfall are too dark for me maybe just need the highlights dodged a little and maybe I would have moved the camera a bit higher.

[level200]

Cheers for your feedback Alf, i'm still learning and will take your suggestions onboard when i work on the images.

Cheers
John

[alfbranch]

Originally Posted by level200

Cheers for your feedback Alf, i'm still learning and will take your suggestions onboard when i work on the images.

Cheers
John

John
Why have you removed your images they ar epretty good despite my comments?

I am still learning after 26 years of photography and have a lot to learn still