Quote:
Originally Posted by ABERS
It would be interesting to hear what proposal you put to the hospice and its patients as to what good or what purpose could be served by your photographing the facilities and the patients. Will it raise money for the hospice, will it bring comfort to those people who are suffering from this terrible and terrifying scourge, will your feeble efforts make any difference whatsoever or will it just further your own photographic career and aspirations?
Please don't come back with the excuse that you are a documentary photographer who wants to record that hospices are not all doom and gloom. It is true that cancer sufferers need to be able to forget things from time to time, but being photographed to satisfy your aspirations isn't one of them.
I speak from experience. My wife has been fighting the disease for 11 years, having undergone three major operations and three courses of chemotherapy and she doesn't need reminding of it by people like you, who lightly state and think it would be better illustrated in colour rather than B+W.
|
You really are a horrible little man, Abers. Sorry but its got to be said.
I did not put forward a proposal to the hospice, it never entered my mind.
Firstly, I am a volunteer at the hospice and was approached by the charity fund raising team to make these photographs for new literature that they wanted to both promote the hospice and raise more money as it relies on volunteers and donations. I never approached them, they asked me and I agreed to give up my time yesterday afternoon to do so. I also photographed their drag walk for them last year and gave them 200 hi-res images for nothing. This year my images were used in new posters and brochures. Again, I was asked by them and did not put myself forward at all.
Secondly I was asked by the patients and staff to make the images colourful and joyful as they wanted the hospice not to be represented as a place to die but a place where people go for support and live. You really should not make comments unless you know the facts.
As for furthering my photographic aspirations, are you kidding?
I have no photographic career to further. I have not been paid for a single photograph in the whole 3 years I have been photographing. I didn't even get paid for the bbc shot, I added it to their flickr group. I am not and never will be a pro photographer. You really shouldnt make comments unless you know me personally.
I don't go out of the house on my own, I need my husband with me at all times. He gave up his career as a clinical psychologist to be my carer. The only place I go on my own is college and that took a very long time to do. And even then my husband takes me and picks me up. He was with me in the hospice yesterday!
My only realistic aspiration is to go to Newport Uni to study documentary photography and even then my husband would be coming as my carer. My photographic future Abers is simply posting my work to these boards and entering comps like DPOTY.
I really wanted constructive feedback so I could go back to the hospice on Thursday and do a good job for them.
Karen