Digital Camera World Forum

Digital Camera World Forum (http://www.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/index.php)
-   Photo critique (http://www.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Hardwater Mill (http://www.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/showthread.php?t=9961)

Jediboy 22-01-13 06:15 PM

Hardwater Mill
 
A Mill local to where I live. Hadn't planned on photographing this today but drove past it on my way to pick my eldest up from school, and it looked quite appealing in the mist and snow.
Any crit welcomed.
Thanks

Chris

[IMG]http://media.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/gallery/files/8/7/8/6/5/hardwater_mill_2013.jpg[/IMG]

markgozz 22-01-13 07:55 PM

I really like the subtle colours which is why I would have to tone down the red life ring , apart from that it looks like a lovey peaceful place and you've done a great job on the composition .

Very nice image well done

Mark

Jediboy 22-01-13 08:30 PM

Thanks Mark.
I thought about getting rid of the life ring, but decided that the colour added a bit of, well, colour, in an otherwise not very colourful image. I'll have a look at toning it down a bit.
Thanks for looking and taking the time to comment.

Chris

Markulous 23-01-13 09:52 AM

Personally, I like the lifebelt - adds some extra interest to a great shot. But I do want to CCW rotate by a couple of degrees!

Jediboy 23-01-13 02:06 PM

Thanks Markulous.

I've converted to black and white:

[IMG]http://media.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/gallery/files/8/7/8/6/5/hardwater_mill_b_w.jpg[/IMG]

Jediboy 23-01-13 02:08 PM

And here it is in colour with the Life buoy toned right down.
I think I prefer the first one, I like the colour.

[IMG]http://media.digitalcameraworld.com/forum/gallery/files/8/7/8/6/5/hardwater_mill_2013_1.jpg[/IMG]

Markyboy1 23-01-13 04:39 PM

The first works best for me Chris although the BW conversion is nice too. The third with the bouy toned down seems weird having seen it in color Nice Shot :)

Mark

Jediboy 23-01-13 06:30 PM

Thanks Mark. Appreciate the comments.

Sabrina_De_Winter 23-01-13 06:40 PM

I both like the first and the B&W one.

I agree with Markulous, maybe a little turn CCW to make the horizon more horizontal. (strange sentence, I don't know how to translate, but I think you will understand what I mean ;))

markgozz 23-01-13 06:40 PM

I prefer the colour version but not with all the colour taken out of the ring just toned down a little , in the original the red of the ring looks too over powering but toned down to match the other colours would make for a better balanced result . ( just my taste ) :)

I can't see an issue with the horizon , the vertical lines look fairly upright to me and the scene as a whole has a very pleasing perspective .

Mark


All times are GMT. The time now is 06:00 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.